Understanding Small Business Administration Loans - Peter Shand, Business Development Corporation - Ep. 19

Peter Shand is the CEO of Business Development Corporation (BDC) in Columbia, South Carolina, a mission-based lender that works alongside banks to make loans backed by the U.S. Small Business Administration (SBA). In this episode of Footnotes, John Barnes asks him how SBA lending actually works, when an owner should use it instead of a conventional bank loan, what a lender wants to see in an application, and why debt can be a cheaper and simpler way to fund growth than selling equity. If you run a company between $5 million and $50 million in revenue and you are planning an acquisition, an expansion or a new location, there is a lot here for you.

Does the SBA actually make loans?

Generally no. Peter explains that the SBA has two main programs. The 7(a) program accounts for about three quarters of SBA loans, and it is a guarantee: a lender such as BDC or a bank makes the loan with its own money and obtains a guarantee from the SBA. The 504 program works a little differently, because the SBA guarantees a debenture and the funds come from an investor rather than a lender. In either case you cannot simply call the SBA to apply for a business loan. You go through a lender, and the SBA's standards decide whether the loan qualifies for the guarantee.

"If a business can borrow from a bank, they should."

Peter Shand

When should an owner use an SBA loan instead of a bank loan?

Peter is direct: if you can get the money from a conventional bank, do that, because the rate and terms will probably be better and the requirements lighter. An SBA loan makes sense when the business or the loan carries more risk than a bank can approve. A bank typically wants two years of cash flow history that supports the loan, while the SBA can work from projections. Banks also usually want collateral beyond the loan amount, while the SBA will move forward with whatever collateral is available. A second location or a major expansion is another good fit, because current cash flow may not support the new debt, and projections can.

What do you need to apply?

Every applicant needs a financial package, whether the lender is a bank or BDC: typically three years of tax returns and financial statements, personal financial statements, budgets and, for a newer business, a business plan. Peter says very few owners have ever applied for a commercial loan, so his team guides them through the process and tests their projections against the experience of similar businesses in the portfolio. If a new business projects a huge first year, he will say that most borrowers start more slowly, so look realistically at two years. The SBA also makes lenders justify projections, and BDC will sometimes pull a comparable business from its files to show the level of revenue a business like this could expect.

"Lack of collateral is not a reason to turn a loan down."

Peter Shand

Can a startup or a side business qualify?

Yes, with conditions. Startup loans are hard to find, and BDC makes them selectively. Peter says the businesses that succeed are usually those where the owner does not depend on the new company to pay household bills, because those funds need to stay in the business. A spouse's income, retirement income or an existing job or business can all provide that cushion. Businesses that have been through the lender's selection process, he says, have a very high success rate, because the lender has to be repaid.

Why use debt instead of equity?

Peter says some of his borrowers choose an SBA loan because they do not want a partner, and he notes that a business partnership needs a very strong relationship and agreement on money. Equity investors also expect a large return, he says 10 to 20 percent a year or more, while an SBA 7(a) loan was priced at no more than about 6 percent floating at the time of the interview, which is a cheap form of capital by comparison. Business acquisition is one of the biggest uses: SBA loans offer a low down payment, which lets buyers preserve cash. The program is also flexible, from real estate loans up to $5 million down to inventory or a truck. He adds that there should always be some equity in the business, but if debt is available it may deserve to be the first choice.

What happens when business gets hard?

During the pandemic, Peter says, the SBA stepped up and made loan payments for borrowers for at least six months and in some cases longer, which surprised even lenders. In ordinary hard times, the SBA will not take your call, but the lender will. Because BDC is the lender, it can temporarily modify payments until things turn around. He adds that the SBA prioritizes minority borrowers, women borrowers, veterans and rural businesses, and that BDC is a mission-based lender that covers the whole state of South Carolina with a focus on underserved markets. His advice is to start with your own bank, which can refer you to BDC if the loan is not bankable.

What this means for your own business

Three lessons stand out for owners. First, treat debt as an option and not as a last resort. It can be cheaper and keep ownership simpler than raising equity, and the right structure depends on your numbers. Second, lenders underwrite to your financial package, so clean statements, a credible forecast and a clear plan for the money improve your odds with any lender. Third, a growth move such as an acquisition or a second location is easiest to finance when the projections are built for a lender to test. That is the work we do in business funding and capital planning, debt financing advice and financial forecasting. If you are weighing how to pay for your next move, talk to us about your numbers.

Topics in this episode: Funding · Debt

Read the transcript

Show the full transcript (auto-generated, lightly cleaned; speakers not labeled)

Hey, welcome to another episode of Footnotes. Today we're going to be talking to Peter Shand, the CEO of Business Development Corporation. Business Development Corporation is a business that comes alongside banks that are making loans through the Small Business Administration's various loan programs. Peter's going to talk to us about the ins and outs of SBA lending, the to-dos and not-to-dos, and might even demystify some of that process. Stay tuned.

Peter, thank you for joining us today. We've got Peter Shand, who is the CEO of Business Development Corporation here in Columbia. It's a business that helps people wind their way through the SBA lending process, and we thought you'd be a great guest to talk to people out there about what SBA lending is, what it does and what you should use it for. I figured we'd start with the question of whether the Small Business Administration actually makes loans to people, or where that comes from and where it started.

Great question. There are two main programs at the SBA, the 7(a) and the 504. About three quarters of all SBA loans are 7(a) loans, and that's really a guarantee, so another lender like Business Development Corporation or one of the banks will obtain a guarantee from the SBA, so it's truly the lender's money. The 504 program is a little different: the SBA guarantees a debenture, but the funds come from an investor, not a lender. In general, the SBA does not make a loan. You can't call the SBA to apply for a loan, in general, for these business loans.

So you're still going through a traditional bank or some other lender, and the SBA is saying that if the loan meets certain qualifications, they'll put their stamp on it for the lender, in case the borrower is not able to repay the loan, because business is risky after all.

That's exactly what happens. The SBA has standards, and we help those borrowers either apply for or meet those standards to get the guarantee.

So if you're a business owner watching this and you've probably heard of SBA lending but never really thought about it, and you've bootstrapped your business or used bank lines or credit, how do you know when you should think about using an SBA-backed loan as opposed to something else, whether you want to buy a business, grow your business, or buy equipment?

It's a great question. If a business can borrow from a bank, they should. We tell applicants that if you can get this somewhere other than through an SBA loan, you should. The terms are probably going to be a little better for you rate-wise, and other requirements at a bank would be less than the SBA requires. However, your business and your loan may have more risk than a bank can approve a loan for. The perfect case would be a new or young business that hasn't quite proven itself yet with cash flow. A bank needs two years of cash flow history that can support a loan. If it's not there, the SBA can use projections, so if we're projected to have adequate cash flow in the future, that's a great use for an SBA loan. Collateral is another good area. A bank is going to require collateral, usually over and above the loan amount, whereas the SBA says as long as you've got all the collateral that's available, you can still move forward. Lack of collateral is not a reason to turn a loan down. So there's flexibility on collateral as well.

That's interesting, and I think a lot of people are not aware of it. They may only be aware of the traditional bank model. As a former banker, I'd say over-collateralized loans came on thanks to the financial crisis in 2008 and 2009. One of the things you said that's key is that a young business that may not even have two years of financial results but has good projections that they can present opens up these programs for them to get the capital they need. If someone is that younger business, what do they need to have when they come to Business Development Corporation to start the process?

It doesn't necessarily have to be just a young business or even a startup, but all businesses are going to need a financial package for an application, whether you go to a bank or to a lender like us for an SBA loan. We should have financial records: three years of tax returns and financial statements, personal financial statements, budgets, and a business plan if it's relatively new. Those things help us understand the business and whether it can repay the loan.

I know you're using that for underwriting, but do you ever find yourself doing a little informal business consulting for people?

We have to, yes. Very few people have applied for a commercial loan, much less an SBA loan, in the past, so we have to guide them through the process. Navigating that is a big part of what we do. There's a technical aspect to it, and we advise prospective borrowers based on what we've seen with our existing successful borrowers. If they're coming in with projections showing they're going to make a tremendous amount of money right out of the gate, we'll say that in our experience with startup lending, most borrowers start off a little slower, so let's be realistic and look at two years. Are you doing better in the second year? If you're not doing better in the second year, it's probably not the right business. We can look at one year of losses, and the next year really needs to be self-sustaining.

Do most borrowers achieve that self-sustaining status in the second year, or is that harder than it seems?

The businesses that we loan to, yes. They've been through a rigorous selection process, a lot of application information and approval, and the ones we lend money to have a very high success rate. They have to, because we have to get repaid. If the business isn't successful, we lose on the loan, so we're very selective. We have a strong discipline about the types of young businesses we'll lend to. Usually you have to have some type of outside income other than relying just on the new business. That's one thing a lot of borrowers don't understand. If you're counting on this new business to keep your mortgage payments going and your household expenses paid, that's a lot to ask. Those funds need to stay in your new business to keep things running. Where we've been really successful is when another person in the household has income, so the owner doesn't have to draw money out in the first year or two.

Could it work where someone has a side gig, a day job that's paying the bills, and a side business they're trying to get off the ground?

It could. Maybe they've got retirement income or a retirement account they plan to draw from to fund some of their household expenses, but yes, if there's another business operating, a new business is a great situation for us to lend into. There's existing cash flow and income to the owner, so we're not totally dependent on drawing funds out of the new business.

If you were creating a billboard out on the highway to let people know something about this process, what would it say?

That's funny, because just yesterday I told someone that BDC will never have a billboard. Our model is that we get our loans from the banks. The banks in South Carolina, if they have a loan they can do in-house, should do that, but if there's one that's not being approved but has a lot of merit, that's when they call us in. But if we were doing a billboard, it would say business acquisition financing is available here. That's a really big area for the SBA: a low down payment, since a lot of people want to preserve capital and a bank may ask for a larger down payment. Startup business loans are very hard to find a lender interested in making, because of the risk of not being repaid. We do those under the scenario we just discussed. And last but not least, SBA loans are extremely flexible. The 7(a) loan in particular can make anything from a large real estate loan up to $5 million, down to a small loan to buy some inventory for an existing business or a truck.

It's interesting that you mention startups, because in the startup world it's all about raising money through equity. If they get a loan through you, they're raising money through debt. Could you talk about the advantages of raising money through debt rather than equity?

Sure. We've had borrowers say the reason they got an SBA loan is that they didn't want a partner. Having a business partner can be tough. I hear it compared to being married, and the relationship has to be extremely strong and you have to be on the same page about money and the finances of the business. Some people don't want to take that on. The other thing is that if you ask an investor to come into your business, they're taking on a lot of risk and they want a large return, maybe 10 percent, 20 percent a year, we've seen numbers like that. An SBA loan, even a 7(a) loan, is priced at around 6 percent floating as the maximum rate, and it can go down from there. That's a cheap form of capital if you think about it as replacing equity.

That's a good distinction. A lot of the stories you hear about fundraising are about people raising millions of dollars, and certainly some businesses need that, but most businesses, in the fat part of the curve, don't need to raise tens of millions in a first round. In the work our firm has done, so many businesses don't even consider raising money through debt. That's why it's great to have you on to talk about a program that, sadly, a lot of people, especially startups, have no clue about. The 7(a) especially has gotten good marketing through business acquisition. If you want to buy a business, that's where we send people. Our firm doesn't make loans, but we understand these things. And the collateral and cash flow requirements for traditional bank lending make it almost impossible under current standards to approach a traditional bank if you're just starting out.

It does, and not just at the early stages, but also for mature businesses that are expanding. A good example is a second location of a successful business. Existing cash flow may not support that amount of debt, so you're going to rely on projections, that we expect the second location to do about what the first location did. When you're into projections, it's difficult for a bank to make a loan, because they usually use historic cash flow in their underwriting. So another great use of the 7(a) is expansions, where a major amount of debt is taken on and the cash flow doesn't support it as it stands today.

Projections are made with the best of intentions, and even if someone is looking over their shoulder to rein in expectations, a pandemic can strike and blow away everyone's projections. Say you took a loan with an SBA guarantee, and your business might not fail, but revenue is definitely not there to support the debt payments. What happens at that point?

I've been amazed and so impressed with the SBA over the last 12 months during the pandemic. The SBA really stepped up. For at least six months, and in some cases longer, the SBA made the payments for the borrowers. The payments come to us, we're the lender, and we're expecting to see these new restaurants and hotels we financed make their debt payments, but they've been devastated because they had to close early in the pandemic. The SBA showed a willingness to work with existing borrowers during an emergency like this. That's a benefit we didn't know existed until last year. I'm not sure they'll do it every time there's an emergency, but it was great this past time.

Now let's talk about non-pandemic problems. Business just isn't going well, or a competitor came to the market and business is going slow.

You're dealing with us as a lender. The Small Business Administration will not take your phone call and help work with you on the loan. You have to go to the lender, in this case BDC, and we can be flexible. If there's a problem we can make modifications and temporarily modify the loan payments until things turn around. That's a level of flexibility that most people don't know existed.

People have a fear of debt. A lot of people who lived through the Great Depression are no longer alive, but that mentality has stayed with us culturally, to be wary of banks and of debt. I think you make a good point, and it's one of several footnotes in this interview: if you don't want another cook in the kitchen, a business partner, if you don't want to share control of your company because you sold equity, if you want more flexibility and frankly want to give a smaller rate of return to someone, debt financing is a good alternative. Maybe it shouldn't even be an alternative. It should be looked at as an option that a lot of people don't consider as high on the list as they should.

If debt is an option, it might ought to be the first choice. There should always be equity in the business, whether it's owner's equity or a follow-up stock sale or whatever it is. But if debt is a possibility, it's a great possibility. A lender has to be repaid, so it would never be considered a grant. We talked about projections before, and the SBA does make us justify projections. If a new business comes in with a very high level of projections, we may have to pull out a similar business from our files and show the SBA that this is about the level of revenue a business like this could expect.

Are there special provisions through the SBA to make loans to groups that are minority or female-led businesses?

Yes, it's a priority. Minority borrowers, women borrowers, veterans, rural businesses, those are targets for my company. We're a mission-based lender in South Carolina, we cover the whole state, and our mission is to make loans to small businesses, especially in underserved markets, if we can reach them. That's one of our goals.

Do people in those groups reach out directly to you, or should they still work through a bank first and then approach you through the 7(a)?

They probably have a banking relationship already, so that's the first place to start. We have relationships with all the banks, and their bankers should know of BDC. If they have a need for capital or an SBA loan, they can start with their bank and be referred to us.

Peter, thanks for sharing all this. There were things I learned through our conversation. Where can people find you? Do you have a website?

We do. If you search for BDC of South Carolina, it'll come up on Google. We'd love for you to check out our website. It's actually a learning resource also. The programs are detailed, the criteria, what the program would look like, and whether you'd qualify. We have all that on our website, and if there are questions we're glad to answer them directly. We just suggest they start with their bank in case it's a bankable loan.

Again, Peter, thanks for your time, thanks for sharing this, and for making this resource available to our audience, and thanks for what you're doing.

Thanks for having me here.

Previous
Previous

Weathering Storms in Business and Life - Rita Patel & Marcus Munse, Hotel Trundle - Ep. 20

Next
Next

Building Tech While Growing People - Colin Griffin, Krumware - Ep. 18