The Key to Strategic Expansion - Scott Lambert and Darryl Frick, Steel Hands Brewing - Ep. 43

Scott Lambert and Darryl Frick are the co-founders and co-owners of Steel Hands Brewing in Columbia, South Carolina, and in this Footnotes episode they walk John Barnes through what it takes to build a product that has never been done before, sell it the right way and market it the right way. The conversation starts with a Christmas-party idea and ends with a second brewery in Greensboro, North Carolina. Along the way it covers how they planned a production brewery instead of a small-batch start, how an 18-month brew schedule drives their forecasting, how the three-tier distribution system works, and how COVID shifted where their beer sold. If you run a company between $5 million and $50 million in revenue and you are thinking about expanding into a new market or a second location, their lessons on planning, contracts and cash are worth a listen.

How did Steel Hands Brewing go from a Christmas-party idea to a business plan?

Scott is an architect and Darryl is a good friend. After a few too many drinks at a Christmas party, what started as a joke turned into a couple of years of work on a business plan. They traveled around the country for seminars and made a point of visiting a brewery in every city, because, as they put it, brewery owners are open about what they did right and what they did wrong. They also spent a long stretch asking multiple banks to finance the plan.

Why did they plan a production brewery instead of starting small?

Several banks suggested they start with a small-batch system of about five barrels. The founders said that was not the plan: if you start with small equipment and need big equipment a year later, you throw the first purchase away. They built the whole business plan around a production brewery, which meant researching what kind of system that requires and what volume they would produce each year. The plan grew to include a tap room, food, an outdoor space and live music, because the successful breweries they visited combined several of those pieces.

"The Beer Market in North America is 120 billion dollars right now."

From the episode

Part of the draw was the size of the market. They put the North American beer market at roughly $120 billion, with craft beer at about 13 to 15 percent of it, and asked what would happen if craft grew to 20 or 25 percent.

How do you decide what to make when the consumer is not you?

The founders say they have little to do with what gets brewed. About a year before the interview they hired a national sales rep who handles distributor contacts and negotiations and also studies market trends, including what retailers and distributors want. Their brewmaster knows a thousand recipes, but an award-winning smoked beer he made in Texas did not sell here. India pale ales are still the biggest category nationally, and tastes keep shifting, so they recently ran a fruited IPA series. Their summary: it is not what we like, it is what the consumer wants.

Why does an 18-month brew schedule matter for forecasting?

They are now working on an 18-month brew schedule, planning which brands and package sizes to take to distributors well into the following year. The cycle is longer than it looks. Grocery chains set their shelves in resets, and the founders learned they happen only twice a year, and once a year during COVID. New styles have to be introduced to distributors and retailers many months before they reach the shelf, and shelf space, once taken, stays taken. They also plan package sizes by channel. For example, they are now using 19.2 ounce cans and 16 ounce cans, and convenience stores lean toward higher-alcohol beers in the larger can. When hard seltzers took off, they pushed craft beer out of some cold boxes, so brands that were not already in the store found it even harder to get in.

What surprised them about how the beer actually sells?

They expected the tap room to be where the public tasted the beer and then bought it in stores. Instead, many people who drink their beer have never visited. They also found that the front of the house, with its food, outdoor space and music, took off far beyond what they had planned. The market changed after COVID too. The old consensus was that getting beer into bars, restaurants and hotels (on-premise sales) would drive grocery sales. During COVID the bars and restaurants closed, so on-premise sales fell, while off-premise sales through stores climbed. They started selling cases out of a window, built a beer garden while the pandemic was still on, and hired two or three people, betting that South Carolina would reopen sooner than other states.

How does the three-tier distribution system change the economics?

Beer sales are regulated state by state. In South Carolina, a three-tier system requires a brewery to sell to a distributor, who sells to the retailer. The founders say they liked that structure but did not anticipate how many distributor contracts, terms and conditions they would have to negotiate. They describe a case where a distributor who wants to take over their brand has to pay the current distributor a multiple of its volume, and the brewery gets nothing from that transaction. They did not want to own trucks or carry the liability of drivers. The volume their equipment produces also means they cannot justify selling only in the tap room, so distributors are part of the plan from the start. As John puts it, there is always more than one customer.

What did they learn from opening a second location in Greensboro?

The Greensboro brewery opened the summer before the interview. It has a smaller system, designed differently, because making specialty and tap-room beers on the big Columbia system was inefficient and used up tank space. The Columbia tap list went from about 14 beers to about 18, with the added beers coming from Greensboro, and the goal is to produce seven or eight beers in each location. Greensboro also supports a "tank series" of kegged beer aimed at bars that want a constant rotation of new taps. The logistics are complicated: beer moved between the two breweries is sold to the local distributor and bought back at retail, like any other brewery's beer. Because most distributors will not carry beer across state lines, a friend started a trucking company to move it. They also see Greensboro as a test: if a local point of production lifts the market there the way it did in Columbia, they may repeat the model once or twice more.

"Almost like four or five businesses wrapped up in a one."

From the episode

Both founders also keep day jobs while running the company.

What this means for your own business

Four lessons stand out for owners who are planning to grow. First, plan the capital you need for the business you actually want, not the version a lender finds easiest to approve, and be ready to show the numbers that support it. Second, forecast on the real cycle of your market, which here is 18 months, because the timing of retailer resets and distributor contracts sets when you can sell and when cash comes in. Third, map every customer in the chain, including the ones who never touch your product, and read the contract terms before you sign. Fourth, test a second location or market on a small scale and measure it before you repeat it. That is the work we do in financial forecasting, cash flow management and funding strategy. If you are weighing an expansion, talk to us about your numbers.

Topics in this episode: Forecasts · Cashflow · Funding

Read the transcript

Show the full transcript (auto-generated, lightly cleaned; speakers not labeled)

Today we're going to be talking to Scott and Darryl, who are the co-founders and co-owners of Steel Hands Brewing here in Columbia. This episode is about more than just beer. It's about how to create a product that's never been done before, how to sell it the right way, how to market it the right way, and basically to live to tell about it. Stay tuned, I think you're going to like this.

Thanks for having us here today for this episode of Footnotes with Scott Lambert and Darryl Frick of Steel Hands Brewing. We've got some of the product here in front of us. I think it's a Pilsner. We've already enjoyed a little bit of it, so hopefully this goes okay.

When we were getting to know each other and setting up for this interview, it was interesting that you said this really started from a conversation you had at a Christmas party. That's correct. You decided, let's make some better beer. Maybe it sounded like a joke at first, but here we are. Did it really happen that way at a Christmas party?

Yeah. My day job is an architect. I'm at an architecture firm here in town, and Darryl is a good friend of mine. We always had Christmas parties together for years, and after probably a few too many drinks one night we came up with this idea of starting Steel Hands Brewing. What started as sort of a joke after several beers turned into a couple of years working on a business plan together, and basically begging multiple banks to finance our dream. That's kind of how it started.

You said it took a couple of years. So it didn't go from a conversation to, let's go buy the equipment or brew it in our garage. What was it like from when you had the idea to when you were actually making batches of beer?

One aspect of the business plan that developed out of a lot of conversation and travel: Darryl and I are in business together, and we travel all over the country to different seminars. Every time we landed in a city, we tried to find a brewery. That turned into gaining experience from talking to the people who own the breweries. In general, brewery owners are very open to conversation. Over our travels they will tell you everything they did right and what they did wrong, so it's a pretty open community. We began working on a business plan together, and it took a couple of years to develop. Part of it was the production brewery. A lot of the banks were looking at us beginning with a small-batch system, a five-barrel system or something like that, and kind of said, why don't you just start small? Well, that was not the plan. The plan was to be a production brewery, so you can't really start small. If you use small equipment, you basically get rid of all that equipment a year down the road and go buy big equipment. So we set the whole business plan on a production brewery, which turned into a fair amount of research on what kind of system that means and what volume you would produce a year. Ultimately that developed into a bigger business plan that included not only the back-of-house production but also the front of house, a tap room. A lot of the successful breweries we visited had multiple components to the tap room. Part of it was obviously great beer, number one goal, but also being able to serve food, and another big component was having an outdoor space where people can gather and have activities, and then live music. Combining all those components into a business plan was really the impetus behind Steel Hands.

For a consumer who just visits, they think Steel Hands is what we're sitting in right now. They know you make beer and you can get it at the grocery store. But it sounds like you had to make sure the business was solid on the back end, in terms of production, before the more visible things for the consumer were out there. It does seem kind of backwards. People want to say, let's start a brewery, and they think about this part, where you can go to live music.

Nothing's easy. It's a brewpub, that's what it's called, and all the beer that's made is just sold in the tap room, so you don't have to pay that much attention to quality and repetition. But when you put it in a can and send it out to a grocery store, it's got to have a shelf life and it's got to taste the same every time, and that's hard to do at small scale. That was one aspect. We really planned on the tap room being the gravy on top of the back of the house. It turned out to be a lot more than we anticipated, with people coming out, bringing their kids out here and listening to music. It was a great surprise that the front of the house took off. Most of our concentration was on the back of the house: the right equipment, the right brewmaster, putting all those pieces into place took a while. But for me a lot of the interest was just the size of the beer market. The beer market in North America is 120 billion dollars right now, and craft beer occupies about 13 to 15 percent of that space. So what if that became 20 or 25 percent? I read up on a bunch of stuff, and a couple of years ago beer passed milk in terms of packaged products sold in North America. It's bottled water, soda, beer is number three, then milk and juices. It's a huge market, so capturing just a small piece of it would be great.

A 120 billion dollar market is a huge number that most people wouldn't realize, and craft is only about 12 or 13 percent of that, so there's a lot to grow into. It is a consumer product, and people want to enjoy it and drink it. How do you decide what you're going to make, whether IPAs or Pilsners or stouts? Is it just you two, since you own it, so you get to pick all the flavors, or how does that work?

We actually have very little to do with that, truth be known. About a year ago we hired a national sales rep. He's not only handling all the distribution contacts and negotiating, he's also researching market trends. We're looking nationwide at how the beer market is changing, what's popular, and what our retailers and distributors are looking for. There's a fair amount of research over the last year that we've been focusing on. When we first started it was primarily our brewmaster and what we wanted to do, but as you get further into distribution there's more strategy that we're infusing into the process. It's not what we like, it's what the consumer wants, and trying to figure that out is tough. Our brewmaster has a thousand recipes in his head, legitimately. For instance, his award-winning beer out in Texas was a smoked beer. It tasted like it had a big smoky flavor, but it just didn't go over here. Just because he likes it or we like it doesn't mean it's going to sell. IPAs are still the biggest market nationwide, so that has developed over the last several years, with different genres of IPAs. We recently did a fruited IPA series. It's ever changing, and trends change, from the most hoppy beer you can have to more fruited IPAs, and that trend continues to change.

Does that affect you on the business side? You have an expert watching the trends who knows the technical factors for making the product, but how does that impact your planning for the business?

We're working on an 18-month brew schedule now, so we're forecasting well into next year, really all of next year and the rest of this year, on what brands we're going to market and what we're taking to our distributors. One thing Darryl and I have learned is that it's a much longer cycle than it may appear. We have to introduce our new styles of beer to our distributors and retailers now for next year. There are certain times during the year they get into what they call their resets. The grocery store chains in particular, we're meeting now and starting to talk about the brands they're going to put on the market in April of next year. So we have to plan what our offering of beers will be, not only in terms of the flavors but also in terms of the package sizes. Something newer that we're doing now is 19.2 ounce cans, and we're also doing 16 ounce cans. Each of those package types is somewhat specific to where it's going to end up. For example, in convenience stores there's a lot of movement toward a higher ABV, higher alcohol content, in a 19.2 ounce can. All of those are aspects of what we're planning for the next year and a half.

We have to be a little bit out there. We didn't realize going into this that grocery stores only reset twice a year, and during COVID it was once a year. You can't just go in and say, hey, sell my product. You have to wait until the next set, because the shelf space is already taken by certain brands in certain locations. There's a science to it, and every store is different, so you have to figure out each store and what they're looking for and how much space they have. Over the last couple of years, for instance, seltzers became very popular and pushed a lot of craft beer out of the cold box because they wanted more room for the seltzer. If you weren't there, it was even harder to get into a Publix or a Harris Teeter or a Lowe's. There's a whole art to that, and we still figure it out.

What are some more of those lessons? I've learned a lot just talking to you, and I think people listening will get an idea that it's more than going to the tap room and enjoying yourself. The work that goes into creating what you enjoy here starts a year to a year and a half in advance, and when you pick it up at home, all those wheels went into motion long before. What are some other lessons you've learned along the way?

One thing that's interesting is what we predicted and I'm not sure has come true. We always envisioned the tap room as a place where the public would come and taste the beers, and that would translate into what happens in the market. We continue to be surprised that a lot of people who drink our beer have never been here. We built this facility so we think people are going to come here, and then someone says, I love your tropical IPA, and I ask, did you first try it in the tap room? They say, no, I've never been to your place. It's kind of funny. The market has also changed a lot, particularly post-COVID. The consensus back in the day was that you get salespeople, and our salespeople work directly for us so we don't depend on the distributor to do all the heavy lifting. We try to get out ahead of them. The general consensus was that if you get your product into on-premise places, which are bars, restaurants and hotels, that will translate into people buying in the store. During COVID all the bars closed and all the restaurants closed, so none of that could happen. We started selling beer by the case out the window here and people started showing up, and then they would see it in the stores. Thank goodness during COVID we had a canning machine, because our on-premise sales went way down but our off-premise sales, which are stores, skyrocketed, because people were buying at the store and taking it home.

Lessons learned: we tried to anticipate COVID coming back, and I think we did a pretty good job. We figured South Carolina would probably loosen up quicker than others, so during COVID we hired two or three people. It was very risky. We built this beer garden out here while COVID was going on, anticipating Memorial Day, which almost happened. Everybody else was sitting around waiting, wondering what to do. On day one we were open.

Let's talk about surprises. The way beer is sold in this country is very state by state. South Carolina is a three-tier system, which we like, but we have to sell our beer to a distributor who sells it to the retailer. The challenge becomes multiple distributors, multiple contracts and multiple terms and conditions. We didn't anticipate all the negotiations that go on, what these contracts really mean and how long they run. If another distributor comes to our distributor and says we want to sell Steel Hands, that distributor has to pay the other distributor something like five times volume, and we get absolutely nothing for the transaction. But we don't want to own trucks and we don't want truck drivers and all that liability. Now we're in North Carolina, so there's a whole different set of rules.

It sounds like when you start making beer, your first customer is really finding a distributor who will take you on to get you into more retail markets, or is it trying to sell it in a tap room? Who are you trying to get on board first?

All of the above. Based on the system we invested in and the volume we're able to produce in the back of house, you really can't justify only selling that beer in the tap room. Based on the business plan and the volume we anticipated brewing, it only makes sense to have distributors.

One of the lessons there is that there are always more than one customer. There's the customer who enjoys it themselves, and then, with the three-tier system, a distributor who has to see some potential in it that they can sell to all their people, and so on down the line. This is a fascinating business in terms of the part you can see and everything behind the scenes that's unseen. I won't hit you with a bad pun about what's on tap, but what is next? I think you just opened in Greensboro this summer. Is it similar to this, or is it just a brewpub? Are you canning up there?

The most unique thing about the difference between the two is that it's a smaller system in Greensboro, designed somewhat differently. One of the struggles for our business here was that we have a big system with big tanks, and producing just tap room beers or specialty beers tends to be inefficient for us and takes up a lot of tank space. Up until recently we had about 14 beers on tap and now we have about 18, and the difference is being made in Greensboro, so we're importing beer from Greensboro down here and streamlining the business here. Our goal is to produce about seven or eight beers here and have seven or eight produced in Greensboro that would be shipped down, not just for tap room consumption but also out into the market. With that system another part of the game plan is what we're calling the tank series. We're producing kegged beer that will go out into the market. There's a big focus among on-premise accounts, which are always wanting something new. We call it rotation nation on the taps. We weren't fulfilling that need given our size of production here, and Greensboro allows us to fill it. Even though it only recently opened, we're already bringing those beers in throughout South Carolina. We're selling in Greenville and soon Charleston and Columbia. It's a whole other kind of business plan, on-premise draft for accounts that want constant new beers, which was difficult here as we're focused more on canned beer and a larger production model.

We've got a full-blown tap room there, bigger than this one, and a distributor up there just like we do here, but it looks a lot different. It gets complex, and so do the finances of selling beer from here to there and from there to here. For instance, up there we have beer that's made here that we want to sell in our tap room just like we sell it here. We have to sell it to the distributor there, and he sells it back to us at retail, just like he does any other brewery. So we have to be strategic about what we're going to brew where, how much we think it's going to sell, and how to minimize the transportation costs, the overhead and the kegs. And how do you get the beer across state lines? Most distributors won't carry beer across state lines, so one of our friends started a trucking company on the side to transfer it back and forth, with all the appropriate licenses. There's a lot of logistics when you cross state lines and start a business in another state.

Talking about the future, our plan was to continue to grow. It has not been without pain, for sure, but we're testing now in Greensboro. If you have a local point of production where everything is created, does the market look like it does here in Columbia? Said another way, we tend to struggle outside the Columbia market. Charleston, Greenville and Spartanburg are successful, but not anything close to Columbia. If we can replicate this in Greensboro, and that local market including Raleigh takes off like this, then we've figured out what we need to do, and maybe we do it one or two more times. In North Carolina you can have three remote tap rooms, so maybe we experiment with just a tap room serving beer made in Greensboro and see what the financials look like. There are a lot of pieces: the food component, the live music and entertainment component, the tap room and the back of the house. It's almost like four or five businesses wrapped up in one, but we want to keep growing.

That's the interesting point Scott and I were talking about earlier, the multiple businesses under one roof. It's not just the beer, it's the front of the house and the back of the house, a restaurant that operates here, and booking entertainment that people want to come and see, which is good for the community and also good for the business. Thank you for doing what you're doing. It sounds like a lot, and I'm sure it is. All the things you've learned about alcohol laws, and having to buy beer from yourself to sell back to yourself, and you still have day jobs. As a member of the community that enjoys it, thank you for operating a great business.

Awesome, thank you.

Previous
Previous

Forging New Markets - Jenn Randall-Collins, Proof Alcohol Ice Cream - Ep.44

Next
Next

Building the Innovation Industry - Bryan Murdaugh, Fivable - Ep. 42